Stanford University has been engaging students in discussions on complex issues through a series of “Civic Salons.” These gatherings, part of the university’s Civic, Liberal, and Global Education (COLLEGE) program, aim to foster open-ended conversations on topics such as free speech, immigration, and economic inequality.
Pamela Karlan, a legal scholar from Stanford and former Justice Department official, recently participated in one such event at Otero. She advised students to consider their strengths and how they might impact the world. Her talk was based on Albert O. Hirschman’s framework for responding to injustice: exit, voice, and loyalty.
Juliet Brodie from Stanford Law School moderated the discussion with Karlan. She encouraged students to reflect on how Hirschman’s concepts applied to their own experiences. The conversation prompted lively debate about resistance and its challenges.
Jayden Moore, a student who attended the salon led by Paul Brest on free speech earlier this year, noted that these discussions offered new perspectives and inspired his academic work. Another student, Will Gibbs, appreciated the depth of exploration provided by Civic Salons.
The initiative is part of ePluribus Stanford’s efforts to promote critical inquiry across campus. Dan Edelstein emphasized that these dialogues help students navigate complex issues without fear of making mistakes.
Freshman Jose Vasquez highlighted the importance of mutual respect for differing opinions within these discussions. The personal format of Civic Salons allows students to engage directly with faculty experts like Jay Hamilton while exploring pressing societal topics.
Hamilton holds several positions at Stanford including Vice Provost for Undergraduate Education and Director of the Journalism Program. Edelstein also serves as a professor in the School of Humanities and Sciences.
###
